Sisters By The Pool -S01 E58

Story 2 months ago

Sisters By The Pool -S01 E58

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 58

I finally decided to tell Neil everything. I told him about Danielle, Hailey, and even a bit about Melanie. I left out the cheerleaders because even I didn't think that sounded like a believable story.

"So if you pick Danielle, you get comfort, sexuality, and there's a solid relationship history now" he analyzed. "Well, aside from the sex with all the other girls."

I laughed and made an underhand foul shot. "That's H - O" I said.

"Just like..." Neil started.

"Don't even" I interrupted, tossing the ball at him.

"And if you pick Hailey, you get adventure, possibly more sexuality, but a bit more of the unknown" he continued.

"Right, I mean we've never actually dated" I said. "We had one night at her house. She's wise beyond her years with some things, but insanely immature with others. There's no guarantee we'd last."

"How do you describe it to her when she's feeling vulnerable..." Neil repeated my quote from Hailey when she accused me of exaggerating my emotional connection with Danielle. "Damn, that's cold."

"I know" I followed up. "Those words haunt me, too. I mean, there might be a little truth to it. But I really do feel connected with Danielle. It feels more like a relationship."

"I can't make this call, man" he responded. "Whatever you do, just go with what you think will make you the happiest, long term. Jokes aside, I'm here for you and hope you make the right call."

...

I took some time to myself away from the girls. I spent hours thinking about everything that had happened over the years. I still remembered how nervous I was the first time I ran into Danielle and learned she lived so close to me. How I never could have dreamed about fucking her and Hailey that first afternoon in their pool. And all the madness that followed, from late nights with the entire cheer team to seeking out Melanie for fun away from the girls.

Danielle and I got along so well. Hailey had sure made a strong pitch with her date night.

I admit, I even did a little research into housing in Utah.

But, at the end of the day, I knew both girls wanted me to themselves. And, whoever I went with wasn't going to allow the crazy to continue, while the other would be looking for something else anyway.

It had been a few weeks since I saw either girl. I had kept in touch through text, and they knew I was mulling my life. I'm sure they both knew exactly what was on the line.

...