My Life - S01 E40

Story 2 days ago

My Life - S01 E40

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 40

Seconds Later.

"You've been screwing both of us?!" Lyla spoke first. My eyes widened in terror, and my mouth opened as if I had a response that didn't exist yet. "Well?" My eyes shifted between the two of them, Lyla was clearly mad, but Shelby looked hurt.

"Yes." Was all I could utter. They both stared at me, expecting me to elaborate.

"That's all you have to say?" Lyla said

"How did this even start? You had me so you figured that you'd fuck my mom too!" Shelby finally spoke up.

"Nol... It wasn't like that."

Then what was it like?"

"Your mom" I motioned to Lyla "actually took my virginity." Shelby's eyes widened and she turned to look at Lyla.

"So those rumors were true! You were going around sleeping with boys after dad! Shelby yelled at her mother.

"No!" I interjected before Lyla said anything. The rumors WERE true, but didn't want Lyla to either admit to it, or have to lie to her daughter. "That's not how it happened. I was still a virgin and my girifriend... EX girlfriend... wanted to take things further, but I was nervous that I'd make a fool of myself, so my mom talked to Lyla and asked if she'd be willing to help me out by getting my first time out of the way, and showing me how to be a good lover."

"Your mom? You talked to your mom about wanting to lose your virginity?" Shelby was shocked.

"My mom and I are... close.." I made eye contact with Lyla, the image of her and my mother sharing the taste of my cock flashed through my mind. "We talk about stuff."

"And you did it?!" Shelby turned back to her mom.

"It wasn't some tawdry or filthy affair!" Lyla defended. I thought back, remembering fucking her while she ate out my mom... so some of it was filthy. I laughed to myself. "I didn't come on to him or try to seduce him, it was a favor."

"And we didn't do it again, after that." I interjected. "Not until recently, when I broke up with Danielle. I was heartbroken and emotional, and I turned to her, and she comforted me." Shelby seemed to understand that a bit.

"Then when did things start with Shelby?" Lyla asked. Shelby suddenly realized that I might tell her mother about the incestuous three way I walked in on. She looked at me pleading.

"Well I was really mad about Danielle, and was looking for a way to get over her, and was talking to Shelby and found out that she wanted a way to get over her asshole ex, so it just happened." I looked at the two of them. Shelby looked relieved that I didn't say anything, and Lyla seemed ok with my story. "Listen, I wasn't trying to betray anybody, or use either of you... Its just that liked it. Lyla is the first woman I ever slept with and she was being kind by sleeping with a loser like me" was laying it on thick, hoping for sympathy, "and I really like Shelby, it started to feel like we were sorta dating, it was nice. And once it happened I knew that if I said anything, then you would both be hurt and mad at each other, and I didn't want that." I sincerely didn't like to lie, but it was the only way I was getting out of this alive.

The two of them sat there, obviously mulling over the story I'd given, deciding what to do. I knew they both liked the sexual relationships they had with me, they just needed to decide if they liked it enough to forgive me. That's the best I could hope for now, was forgiveness, because even if they did, they'd still never have sex with me again.

"You and I weren't in any type of relationship, so we definitely weren't exclusive.." Lyla spoke first, "so I'm not upset that you slept with someone else, I was upset that it was my daughter, it felt like you were using us both, but if that's not what it was, then I forgive you

"I guess I feel the same way." Said Shelby.

"I'm not saying I did nothing wrong, I was just nervous and wasn't sure what to do, so I just avoided doing anything... I'm sorry, really, I care about you both, didn't want to hurt you."