Sarah's submission - S01 E167

Story 1 month ago

Sarah's submission - S01 E167

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 167

Sarah laughed and patted Natalie's knee. "It's okay. You can say slutty! I definitely can be. But I don't want everyone to know about it. So we are all really careful." Natalie still looked stunned. Sarah kept her hand on Natalie's knee intentionally.

She watched Natalie's eyes look carefully at her hand touching her, but waited patiently and didn't move it. After a minute, Natalle asked timidly, "So you've done it with just girls too? Like a lesbian thing?"

"Yes. I don't consider myself a lesbian, but I do like having sex with girls. Have you ever tried it?"

"Had sex with a girl?" Natalie responded rhetorically. The blush confirmed for Sarah that Natalie was curious, and she still didn't try to remove Sarah's hand. "No."

"Do you think you would want to try? Or try a threesome?"

Natalie seemed to consider before slowly shaking her head." don't know if I could. I mean, a lot of people already think I'm.... trashy. If something like this got around...I just don't think I could."

Taking it slow, she wanted to be careful to not scare the girl. "So it's not that you aren't interested, it's just that you are worried about what other people might think, right?" she asked very softly.

Pulling her eyes up, she looked Sarah straight in the face. "I guess so," she replied quietly.

"What if I could promise you that the boys won't talk about it. That as long as you don't say anything, nobody but us would know about it?"

Natalie shook her head. "How could you do that? Guys always talk about sex. They always brag." She seemed thoughtful for a long minute. "Half the reason I dress like this is because once I started letting guys feel me up, it spread around like crazy and everyone would call me a slut or a whore. I mean, I have big tits, so they are always grabbing and trying to see them or whatever. I finally figured, if I am going to get called that anyway, I might as well look the part." She seemed sad.

"I get it," Sarah said nodding sympathetically. "We all feel that way. But I can promise because I've done it. And I can tell you how and I promise that I will do it for us this time as well."

"Ok. How?" she asked, now obviously intriguing.

"I get them to do something embarrassing and make a video. Kind of the price to get me to do something they want. That way, if they ever try to spread a rumor about me, I'll spread something much worse about them. Something that they definitely wouldn't want to get out about them."

"So blackmail. Like what?" she asked with a conspiratorial tone.

Sarah shook her head. "It's only blackmail if I use it to hurt them. I don't want to ever show it to anyone. So it's more like insurance. Because I only need to make sure that they will keep things to themselves. Same thing goes with girls. I can't share secrets about the boys without being sure I can trust in your silence." Taking a brief pause before she continued, "But I will share if you will do something for me."

Natalie scowled and looked suspicious. "What do I have to do?"

"Let me make a video of me fucking you with a strap-on dildo," she stated.

Natalie didn't react right away, but then threw her head back and laughed loudly. "You can't be serious!"

"Yes I'm serious. Look Natalie, I know you are curious. I can see it in your eyes. You want to know what sex with another woman is like. Probably have been curious to try for a long time. I know I was. And you want to know what I have over the boys. Which I promise will more than satisfy you. You are also thinking about how great it would be to try having more than one cock at a time after prom. Which again, I can promise is even better than you can Imagine. But I need to be able to trust you."

Natalie shook her head and eyed Sarah for an extended period while she considered. "Do you have one?"

"A strap-on? Sure."

"Can I see it?"

"Of course!" Sarah got off the bed and reached underneath to her hidden stash of toys. She pulled the box out and took out some sweaters that covered the incriminating items. Standing back up. she hooked her fingers into her shorts and underwear and lowered them seductively before stepping out of them and Immodestly showed off her perfect peach.

"Do you wax your pussy?" Natalie exclaimed. "It looks so smooth."