Sarah's submission - S01 E165

Story 1 week ago

Sarah's submission - S01 E165

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 165

Conner called Sarah later that afternoon with the good news that he had found the extra couple to join them for prom night, Joe and Natalie. Joe being another football player didn't surprise Sarah. She knew him of course, but not well. With his dark hair and a dark complexion, Sarah guessed he probably had an Italian heritage. Attractive and strong as an ox, Sarah immediately pictured him fucking her while she clutched his tight abs, bringing a quick tingle to her pussy.

Natalie also presented an interesting option. Being in the grade below Sarah, she didn't know Natalie as well, but she definitely had a reputation as a party girl and acted pretty slutty most of the time, so that boded well. Sarah guessed Natalie to be 5'7" or 5'8" tall with very blonde hair, almost platinum. Given that it most likely came out of a bottle, Sarah wondered what her natural hair color might be. She always wore a lot of eye makeup, sometimes with sparkle accents, and cheap clothes that showed off her enormous boobs. Walking down the hall, her tits usually looked ready to bounce out of whatever tight, low-cut top she wore. Nevertheless, Sarah couldn't deny that Natalie had some real beauty under the cheap adornments.

At parties, Natalie was usually either very drunk or very stoned, or both, and all over whatever guy she was with. She had started dating Joe earlier in the school year and had calmed down a lot, but still wore her very trashy clothes. Sarah knew that Natalie's family had even less money than hers and thought she remembered that her parents were divorced. Having heard the rumors that Natalie's mother suffered from alcoholism, which probably led to why her father had wanted out, also probably explained why Natalie acted the way she did.

"Hmm. Probably not my first pick, but not bad. And you are sure they are down for what we have planned? You explained everything?" she asked.

"Well, I talked to Joe. He said that he and Natalie had talked about having a threesome before and she seemed down with it. He definitely is. He wants to bang you and Jenny for sure."

Sarah sighed. She could tell he hadn't really prepped them at all. "Did you tell him that it is going to be a full-on orgy or not?"

She heard Conner groan and he stammered, "I said that the girls wanted to take turns having sex with us. And he told me that Natalie would play along. He was sure of it."

"God damn it Conner! That's not what I told you. We want to have a full-blown orgy. Not taking turns. I don't want this whole thing ruined because they freak out when we really get started. Did you even tell him about the rest of it? About the pegging?" she asked emphatically while covering her mouth with her hand as much as possible to make sure nobody else in the house heard.

"Well, no. But figured that if he saw us doing it, that he would go along. Or maybe we should just skip that part."

Sarah tried to calm herself, but she could feel the anger bubbling up. "Do you want to fuck my ass or not? Have three girls blow you at the same time? Do you ever want to fucking touch my pussy again?!" she said exasperated. "Look, this is going to be one of the greatest nights of your life. But not if you screw it up for me, understand? You get him to agree to what I want, or you never get to fuck any of us ever again! And you can find a new date for prom or just sit around and jerk off all night!"

"Okay, okay! Relax! I'II...I'll talk to him. Why is this so important? Why can't it just be more..., you know..., normal?"

"I don't want normal Conner. I want what we agreed to, and what you promised you would help me get. I've done a lot for you, right? Given you a lot? And I've kept all of your secrets. You want me to go on keeping your secrets, don't you? Or should I just show everyone the pictures I have? I might just have to do that if you fuck this up for me. I want this night to be perfect"

Conner sighed heavily into the phone. "Fine. I'll talk to him, and you Conner sighed heavily into the phone. "Fine. I'll talk to him, and you know, explain it. But he gets to fuck your ass too, right? I can promise him that? You and Jenny?"

"Yes, Conner. Tell him that you tried it and it gave you the best orgasm of your life. And he gets to fuck us any way he wants. You make us happy and we do anything you guys want. How many guys would give their left nut for a deal like that?" she chuckled and softened. "I'm sorry. I don't mean to be a bitch. You get him to agree and I'll talk to Natalie and make sure she is 'really' down for this. I doubt he has told her anything. And thank you for helping. 1 do appreciate it and I will make it worth your while. I promise."

"You're gonna kill me girl," he said sarcastically.

"No, I'm going to treat you like a king!" she teased back. "I'll tell you what, you talk to Joe and get him to agree and then come over Monday after school and I'll show you how much I appreciate you?"

Appealing to his lust always worked with Conner. "Deal! I'll get it done. Don't worry." Sarah told him to text her Natalie's phone number before getting off the phone and then laid on her bed trying to think of the best way to make sure Natalie would agree as well.