My high School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E19

Story 1 year ago

My high School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E19

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 19

I looked up and Stacy's hands were now reaching behind her, grabbing Cindy's ass and pulling Cindy closer to her. Her head was arched back, her mouth open, and she was looking straight up between Cindy's legs. Cindy was staring down at her in a daze, but she was arching her hips forward, closer to Stacy, and her knees were sliding further apart.

"Oh FUCK!...JEFF!... I'm... you're gonna make me CUM!"

Stacy started bucking against my mouth, and I fucked her harder with my fingers. I sucked greedily on her pussy, and suddenly a gush of fluid filled my mouth and covered my face. I first thought she had just peed on me, but it didn't taste or smell like pee, and I was so fucking horny I don't think I would have minded if was. I just continued ravaging her pussy, enjoying every moment.

Stacy's body started convulsing, and I could see that she had pulled Cindy so close that Cindy's pussy was just inches above her face. "FUCK!... EAT MY PUSSY!!! OH GOD!! ...JEFF!!" She rode her climax gripping Cindy's ass tightly, trying to pull her down onto her face. A minute longer and I think Cindy would have gone there, but when Stacy's body slumped after her strong orgasm, Cindy scooted back immediately. I pulled my mouth back from her pussy and slid my fingers out, her body twitching with each movement. I looked at Cindy and smiled widely... She smiled back but quickly broke eye contact. She looked embarrassed at what just happened.

well, what had almost just happened

I took Stacy's legs from Cindy, and continued to hold them open, looking down at her swollen pussy gaping open, twice the size and twice as wet as before, and my rock hard cock just inches away. I could fuck her right now. I know I could work my cock into her... her body was tiny, but her pussy was primed and ready. I saw a large drop of pre-cum ooze out the end of my cock. I relaxed my grip on her legs and let them drop, but Stacy held them open for

me. I bent down and sucked on her little titties... those soft round

mounds with the huge areolas... I sucked on her nipples until they were plump and erect. Pulling back, I started stroking my cock right at the entrance of her open pussy. Stacy reached over and grabbed the pack of condoms still sitting there from earlier, looked at me with lust in her eyes and nodded... 'fuck me....

Cindy was watching this, still kneeling on the pool table above Stacy's head, and broke my lustful trance, 'No! This isn't supposed to be the way it happens! You are supposed to take MY virginity, not Stacy's!"

I snapped out of it and realized how rude I was being to Cindy, a girl I loved and would never want to hurt. "God, Cindy... I was getting a little carried away. I'm sorry... L... I'm just a very horny guy and I kinda lose it when my dick takes over. You have to admit... this is pretty erotic."

I walked around and picked her up off the pool table and held her. Stacy was still on her back, holding her legs spread open for me.

"What the hell? Really? So get ignored again?", Stacy said as she pulled herself up from the pool table and got back on her feet. "Cin, you said you didn't think you were ready. That Jeff was too big and you didn't think you could do it."

"I know... I want to, but... he's so big, and I'm so small... I'm scared." Then she looked at me, 'I really do want to make love with you... maybe we could try?" Then she looked at me a little sideways, "Jeff, you are soaking wet!" Cindy looked back at the pool table and the towel was soaked where Stacy had been laying. Stacy shot over and grabbed the towels from the pool table, quickly wiping up any evidence.

"That was probably me. I sometimes get really wet when I cum." Stacy mumbled, and turned bright red. She grabbed her drink from the bar and took a big gulp, obviously very embarrassed.

"I loved it, Stacy... I thought it was really erotic."

I didn't really know what had happened, but it was pretty fucking hot

"Well, you brought rubbers to the party, so ONE of us is going to lose their virginity tonight', Stacy blurted out, then took another gulp of her drink.

"We could try. Maybe... just take it slow and be gentle?" Cindy

offered to me.

"Great! So you two try to do it, and if you can't... then Jeff can fuck me with that big old dick of his!", Stacy stammered out... she was getting sloppy drunk.

Cindy looked at me with great concern. I was certain I would not be able to get my cock inside her tiny pussy. My finger was too big for her.... no way... not tonight anyway.

Cindy smiled and grabbed the towel I dried Stacy with and laid it on the pool table, and motioned for me to come to her. She stood up on her tiptoes and kissed me, then dropped to her knees and put the head of my cock in her mouth. She started sucking on my cock and was trying to take it in deeper, but was only able to take a few inches in before gagging.

This got Stacy's attention and she stumbled over. "You're doing it wrong Cin, You need to take it deeper!", she said in a sarcastic tone.

She came up behind me and pressed her naked body against my back, reaching around me to Cindy's head, which was up against the pool table. Grabbing Cindy's hair, she pulled her head roughly against me, and Cindy gagged hard when the head of my cock hit the back of her throat. This felt fantastic, but I didn't want Cindy to be abused like Stacy had been. I backed up and pulled my cock out from Cindy's mouth, picked her up and set her on the pool table. She laid back on the table and brought her legs up; that beautiful little pussy in full view. Stacy came around to the side and stared blatantly at Cindy's tiny pink slit.

"There's no fucking way that big old dick is gonna fit in there!", Stacy mumbled, and reached out and touched Cindy's pussy. pulling it further open to get a better look at the size of her opening.

Cindy's mouth dropped open and looked at Stacy like WTF?'. She looked back at me, then reached over and grabbed a condom and tried to unwrap it. After a moment or two of trying, Stacy impatiently grabbed it from her, ripped the packet open and handed me the condom. I started unrolling the condom on my dick, but Stacy grabbed it and worked it on the rest of the way; about 2/3 the way up the shaft.

"See? The fucking rubber barely fits! There's no way that's gonna fit in that tiny pussy of yours, Cin."

Stacy's drunk comments weren't helping the romantic setting for Cindy's first time

Previous Episode

My High School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E18

Next Episode

My High School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E20

What's your rating?
0
{{ratingsCount}} Votes