My high School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E15

Story 1 year ago

My high School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E15

Read Story: SEASON 1 EPISODE 15

"Show Stace your panties", Cindy said with a wide smile.

I seized the opportunity. I stood up, pulled off my shirt, unbuttoned my jeans, and pulled them down to my knees. My underwear started coming down with them, so I had to hold the waistband and shuffle my jeans down with my other hand,

I sat back down and reclined the chair slightly. My cock was barely covered by the waistband of my underwear, a large wet spot at the head.

Cindy looked at me, then we both looked at Stacy, who was mesmerized at the sight. Cindy laughed, and skipped the formality, "Show Jeff your bra."

Stacy didn't hesitate on this one. She unbuttoned her blouse, pulled it out from her waistband, and opened it wide to expose herself, evidently quite proud of her growing boobs. Her breasts looked even better bare. Undeveloped, maybe an A cup, but plump and pretty big for her age, with huge areolas and nipples that stood erect, and straight out.

I flexed my cock so it jumped a bit, pulling at my waistband. I knew this would get a rise from Stacy, and she gasped wide-eyed and covered her mouth.

Cindy was really enjoying this. She got closer to me, bent over and stroked my cock through my underwear. When she moved her hand down, the waistband followed, nearly exposing the head.

I reached behind her and ran my hand up Cindy's thigh, under her 'skirt' and felt her ass. Running my fingers between her legs, I pushed them forward, over her ass and started rubbing her tiny pussy. It was dripping wet.

Stacy was staring wide-eyed at the erection in my underwear, her mouth slightly open. "Can I touch it?"

Cindy shook her head, "Only if I say so", and continued stroking me through my underwear. Cindy was savoring being in charge; Stacy was obviously the "alfa female", and wasn't used to this.

"Raise your skirt and show Jeff your kitty", Cindy told her, like she was giving a command.

Stacy looked nervous. She looked up at me, then reached down with both hands and grabbed the hem of her skirt. I noticed her right hand was shaking a little.

"Are you going to show me... your... your thing?", Stacy asked me, but Cindy cut her off. "You aren't seeing anything unless you do exactly as you are told."

Yeah, Cindy was having fun.

I moved my hand around to the front of Cindy's 'dress' and blatantly slid my hand up the front and started rubbing her pussy again. Stacy's eyes broke from mine and shot over to my hand up Cindy's skirt, and took a quick breath. The cocky bravado Stacy had been throwing around had suddenly disappeared. She continued holding the hem of her skirt, locked in place while looking back and forth at my hand up Cindy's dress, and the hard- on in my underwear.

I pulled my hand out from under Cindy's dress, and my fingers were glistening wet. Stacy stared as I put them in my mouth and sucked off the juices, then slid them back up Cindy's dress.

Stacy's mouth dropped, and she quickly pulled her skirt up to her waist, completely exposing her little beaver. She had slightly more hair than Cindy, and it was dark brown. I could see her labia protruding, the lips glistening from her leaking pussy. I noticed her nipples were engorged as well; this was definitely turning her on.

Cindy reached down and raised the waistband of my underwear with one hand, and slid the other over the head of my cock, still hiding it from Stacy's eyes. She pulled her hand out and showed how wet it was to Stacy, then licked her palm.

Another gasp from Stacy. She was still holding her skirt up for me, and I could see a long drip of her lube hanging from her pussy.

'Oh my Gosh, Stace!...you are dripping!" Cindy burst out laughing.

Stacy looked shocked, and reached down and caught the drip with her hand, along with a great deal of lube from her lips. She was obviously embarrassed.

"Oh, and you aren't?" I said to Cindy, and pulled my fingers out from under her dress and showed them to her. "I think it is sexy as hell", then sucked her lube off my fingers again.

Come closer, Stacy", I motioned for her to step towards me. She came within reach, her hand still catching the lube leaking from her pussy. I reached out and grasped her wrist, pulling her hand

away from covering her pussy. Lube dripped from her fingers.

I brought her hand to my mouth and sucked her fingers, one by one, savoring every drop. Stacy looked shocked at what I was doing.

'I suppose you like the taste of her more than me?" Cindy said, watching me do this.

"You both taste delicious, but you know you are always my favorite", I replied, still holding Stacy's hand.

I let go of Stacy's hand and reached out and touched her pussy. It was still dripping wet. Running my fingers over her labia, I found her opening and slid my middle finger inside. Stacy took a quick breath, and her tight opening contracted. She was tight... nowhere near as tight as Cindy, but as tight as you might expect for a virgin her age. Actually, I could slide my finger all the way in her... no resistance. Maybe she had masturbated with her hairbrush or something, but I felt no trace of a hymen.

I started working my finger in her pussy, feeling her G-Spot area swelling at the touch, and rubbing on her clit using my thumb. It seemed to be working, Stacy moved in closer, still holding her skirt up, and squatted slightly and rocked on my probing finger. I pulled out my middle finger and replaced it with two fingers, and started curling them on her G-Spot. God, her tight little pussy felt good.... so fucking tight, but I'm sure I could get my cock in there... it would Just take a little work. I wanted to feed this girl my cock.. I wanted to watch my thick cock slide inch by inch into her....

I think I may have been too focused on flinger-fucking Stacy's tight little hole. Cindy didn't like so much attention going to her friend. "Did I say you could do that?", she said, and reached out and grabbed my hand, pulling my fingers out of her friend's pussy. Stacy shot a look at Cindy, still holding her skirt up, "Really? Who put you in charge?"

Cindy pointed to me.

"Well, yeah, I guess those are the rules", I replied with a smirk, and tried to drown out my thoughts on fucking Stacy, I looked back at Cindy... your move

"Okay, truth, Stace... do you want to see Jeff's cock?"

I was surprised to hear her say the word 'cock'.

"Yes, Show it to me!"

Previous Episode

My High School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E14

Next Episode

My High School Sweetheart's Young Sister - S01 E16

What's your rating?
0
{{ratingsCount}} Votes